Make your own free website on Tripod.com

 

 

 

 

In the name of God the Beneficent the Merciful

SHIA  EMAN BIL QUR'AN

PART-II

QURAN AND ULAMA-E-SHIA

             In part I, we discuss twenty points concerning the Holy Quran and the saying of  A'Emma-e-Ahllal Bait in this part we will high light  the twenty points about the Holy Quran and the saying of Ulama-e-Shia

  1:- Tafseer-e-Safi Pt-1, Page-36

      A great Shi'ee Alem Syed Murtaza affirms,  " The saying of a group of narrators of A'Hadeeth about the transposition of holy Quran is based on A'Hadeeth-e-Zaefa which could not compete those strong A'Hadeeth which are against the concept of transposition of Holy Quran.

   2;- Tafseer-e-Safi

  Sheikh-e-Toosi affirms, " The narrations  about transposition of Holy Quran narrated by Shia and Sunni narrators are those which have only single source of narration therefore, all such narrations are to be rejected.

   3:- Ala-Alrahman Page-17.

    Sheikh Jawad Balaghi affirms, " All those narrations dealing  with the transposition of Holy Quran are not correct because their narrators are not dependable and are suspicious. "

   4:-  Bahrul Fawaid Page- 99.

     Allama Mohammad Hussain Shabani affirms, " All the narrations about the transposition of Holy Quran are Za'eef. "

    5:-  Tafseer-ul-Quran, Page- 233

     Sayed Abul Qasim Al-Khoi the late Marjey of the present century affirms, "All  narrations about the transposition of Holy Quran are Za'eef."

     6:-  Klmo-Tayyab Page - 22

       Syed Abdul Hussain affirms, " All narrations about the transposition of Holy Quran are Za'eef and are unreliable .

     7:-  Ettaqadia Sheikh Saddoq Chapter-11 Page-92.

        Sheikh Saddooq a great Shi'ee Muhaddes affirms, " Our believe about Holy Quran is that this is a Kalam of Allah, His Wahi and his revelation, this is his book and   batel cannot entered in it from any side, and Allah himself is responsible for its protection . This is the same Quran which was revealed on Holy Prophet if anyone attributes its transposition to us is liar   "

     8:-   Tafseer Ala ur Rahman Page-17

           Sheikh Mofeed affirms, " In this Quran , there is no change in its Ayat, Kalama, or Surah. It is perfect and complete. there is non of saying of anybody in it. "

     9:-   Tasfeer Majma ul Bayyan. Page-5,

       Allam Ali bin Ahmed  Tabrasi affirms, "  Unanimously every one believes that nothing  is taken out from the text of Holy Quran and bout the addition in its text some of the sects like Hoshumia belive  so , but we Shia believe that there is not at all any addition or subtraction in the text of Holy Quran. "

     10 :-  Haqa'equl Taweel Page-40.

           Sayed Razi affirms, " This Quran is such a great book of Allah that Batel cannot enter in it from any side. "

      11:-   Taseer-e-Safi Page-33

           Mulla Faiz Kasani affirms, " If it is believed that there is some addition or subtraction in  the text of Holy Quran then the Holy Quran will  not remain a dependable book and it will not remain hujat, and the order of Allah for the following of this book will become meaningless therefore , it is must that all such narrations those deal with transposition are to be rejected.  "

      12 :-  Tafseer Al-Sadeqeen  page-5.

             Fatahullah Kashani affirms, "  The holy Quran is totally protected from all sort of transposition. "

      13:-   Tafseer Ayatul Kursi Page-332.

             Mulla Sadd-rud-deen  Sherazi affirms, " The holy Quran is totally saved from all sort of transposition. " 

      14:-   Aqa'ed-e- Emmamia page-85

              Sheikh Mohammad Raza Muzafar affirms, " There is no change in the text of Holy Quran , the Quran which is in our hand is just the same which was revealed on the Holy Prophet, if any one claims that there is some transposition in the Holy Quran, he is totally wrong. "

     15:-   Massa'eb-un-Nawa'eb. page-105.

                Noor-ul-llah  Showshistari affirms," The allegation  that Shia believe in the transposition of Holy Quran is totally wrong.  All those who narrated such narrations are not dependable and trustworthy.

     16:-   Lawama al-Tanzeel Para-14 Page-23

                 Allama  Ha'eri affirms, " This Holy Quran is totally saved from all sort of transposition"

     17:-  Tafseer Haqani Pt-1, Page-63.

                  Mohammad bin Hasan A-meli affirms, " Anyone who will deeply think on the  narrations will come to know that there is no transposition in the Holy Quran if anyone believe such we do not at all confirm him. "

     18:-   Anees-ul-A'lam Page-28

                    Sheikh Mohammad Toharani affirms, " Continuity of Holy Quran opposes the concept of transposition of Holy Quran. To us Quran is fully protected and we reject him if someone don't agree for this. "

     19:-   Tafseer Al-Mezan Pt-12 Page-104, 110

                     Syed Mohammad Hussain Tabatabai affirms, " The Ayat , "Inna Nahno Nazalna al Zekr wa  Inna lahu lahafezoon" is the grantee against the transposition of Holy Quran, moreover the continuity of Hadeeth-e-Saqalain assures that there is no transposition in Holy Quran otherwise this Hadeeth will become meaningless "

     20 :-   Manaqeb-e-Aly Abi Talib Pt-1 Page-19.

                       Ibn-e-Sehrey Ashoob affirms, "The Holy Book ( Quran ) revealed on Holy Prophet is totally protected from all kinds of transposition ".

          

            The twenty affirmations of Ulama-e-Shia about the holy Quran ended here. In the third part of the article we will discuss about the twenty sayings of Ulama-e-Ahly Sunnah which leads to the the concept of transposition of Holy Quran.

     *****************************************************

next

home